An employer’s unilateral setting of company targets relevant to variable remuneration is a target-setting exercise under section 315 of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch – BGB). The employer must communicate the targets to employees in good time by means of a declaration of intent requiring receipt. Merely setting targets internally cannot achieve the performance-enhancing and motivational purpose of variable remuneration schemes.

Facts of the case

The claimant was employed as a Finance Manager by a company in a US group. Her employment contract provided for variable remuneration amounting to 15% of her annual salary. The bonus calculation comprised an individual performance factor and a “Financial Modifier” based on company targets. The specific arrangements were governed by a works agreement, under which the relevant company targets and financial metrics were to be determined at the beginning of each financial year However, Annex 3 to which the works agreement referred did not exist.

For the 2022 bonus year, the employer did not inform the claimant of the specific revenue or earnings targets applicable to her division. In early 2023, it nevertheless paid her a bonus based on a target achievement level of only 49%. The claimant considered this unlawful and sought damages in the amount of the difference between the bonus paid and her full target bonus of EUR 8,339.40 gross, plus interest.

The claimant argued that the employer had neither communicated the specific targets to her nor made the financial plan referred to in the works agreement known within the company. Without knowledge of the targets, she had been deprived of the opportunity to align her work with the company targets relevant to her bonus. The Labour Court and the Regional Labour Court dismissed her claim.

Decision

The Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht – BAG) upheld the claim and awarded her damages for lost performance-related remuneration. It held that the relevant company targets constituted a unilateral target-setting exercise, the determination of which was for the employer, under its unilateral right to determine performance, pursuant to section 315 BGB.

However, such target setting can fulfil its purpose only if the targets are communicated to employees in good time. Employees must know which targets the employer considers particularly important in order to be able to align their conduct accordingly. The setting of targets therefore required a declaration of intent specifically addressed to the claimant. The mere internal determination of company targets does not satisfy the intended performance-enhancing and motivational function and is therefore insufficient.

In the present case, the employment contract and works agreement required the employer to communicate the specific company targets at the beginning of the financial year. The setting of targets becomes impossible under section 275(1) BGB, at the latest, when the relevant target period ends. Target achievement and so the amount of variable remuneration cannot then be determined, since both necessarily depend on targets having been set in advance. In particular, an employee cannot retrospectively perform work for an earlier period or redirect past work towards targets communicated only at a later stage.

In such circumstances, the entitlement to a bonus is replaced by a claim for damages for lost variable remuneration under sections 280(1) and (3), 283 and 252 BGB. The amount of damages is estimated by reference to the variable remuneration lost, with the employee generally being presumed to have achieved the targets that should have been set. This presumption may only be rebutted where the employer establishes and proves circumstances demonstrating that the employee would not have achieved those targets.

(BAG, 22 April 2026 – 10 AZR 28/25)

Practical takeaway

  • The BAG makes clear that, like an agreed-target scheme, unilateral target setting can serve its intended purpose only if employees know the relevant targets in advance and are able to align their performance accordingly.
  • Employers should review their bonus policies, incentive plans and works agreements and adjust their processes where necessary.